Year 9 · Unit 6 · Lesson 5 · teacher page

Teaching: does the order of two transformations matter?

Combined transformations, full descriptions of each type, and the split between congruence and similarity transformations.

Geometry and TrigonometryNo calculator

At a glance. One lesson of about 60 minutes. Performing two transformations in order, describing a transformation fully, and deciding between congruence and similarity.

Calculator: no calculator. The numbers are small on purpose: the work is in the order, and in testing every point.

What students will learn

Know

  • To combine, apply the second transformation to the image of the first.
  • A full description of a translation needs its vector, a reflection its mirror line, a rotation its centre, angle and direction, an enlargement its centre and scale factor.
  • Translations, reflections and rotations are congruence transformations; an enlargement is a similarity transformation.

Understand

  • The order of two transformations can matter.
  • One point is not enough to identify a transformation: all points must agree.

Do

  • Perform two transformations in a stated order.
  • Identify and fully describe a single transformation from a pre-image and its image.
  • Decide whether a transformation is congruent or similar.

MYP assessment criteria

Wording paraphrased. What this lesson gives you evidence for, and what to look for:

The one thing to do with the figure

Before pressing the second button, ask for the answer. With the first order showing (5, −1), ask: “Where will A end up if I swap the order?” Let them calculate before it appears.

On the second figure, ask: “Which one changed the lengths? How do you know from the numbers?”

A possible order

5 minWarm-up, then answers; dwell on warm-up question 2 (a quarter turn clockwise).
10 minHook, prediction for the two orders, then the first figure.
10 minKey idea; the second figure, naming what you see.
10 minWorked examples; the faded example in pairs.
5 minQuestion 1, the check.
15 minYour turn, Levels 1 to 3.
5 minExit ticket, question 9.

The answers

Warm-up(12, −8); (4, −1); (3, −4).
Worked examples(−1, −1); (−1, −3); reflection in the y-axis; rotation 90° anticlockwise about the origin.
Faded example(4, 1).
1. Two moves in orderB, (3, −5). A reverses the order; C omits the reflection; D subtracts the vector.
2. Translate then reflect−5. Final image (−5, 2).
3. Translate then rotate−3. Final image (2, −3).
4. Identify from two pointsC. Test every point; D works for the first point only.
5. Enlarge then translate2. Final image (2, 8).
6. Describe fullyB. A is true but incomplete; C changes both signs; D works for P only.
7. Area through three moves20. 5 × 4.
8. Work back1. (1, 3) → (3, 1) → (5, 0).
9. Order mattersA. (−3, 2) to (2, 3) to (3, 2). B leaves out the reflection; C reverses the order; D leaves out the turn.

What each wrong answer tells you

They giveWhat it usually meansWhat to do
A, C or D in question 1Reversed the order, skipped a move, or subtracted the vector.Write the point after each move on its own line.
5 or 3 in question 2Skipped the reflection, or reversed the order.Underline “first” and “then” in the question.
3 or −1 in question 3Skipped the turn, or turned the original point.Write the translated point first, and turn that.
A, B or D in question 4Tested one point only, or chose the wrong rule.Test all given points against each rule.
−6 or 10 in question 5Reversed the order, or subtracted the vector.Write the point after the enlargement, then add.
A, C or D in question 6Incomplete description, or the wrong move.Ask: which line? Which centre? Which angle?
10 or 5 in question 7Area multiplied by k only, or not at all.Draw a 2 by 3 rectangle, enlarge by 2, and count squares.
−1 or 0 in question 8Sign slip, or forgot the translation.Write the point with a in it after each move.

Questions worth asking

Differentiation

A way in for anyone stuck

Stretch

Students learning in English as an additional language

Combined, order, congruent and similar are used precisely here. Pair each with a picture: two arrows in a row for combined, and a numbered list for order.

WordPlain meaningExample
combined transformationtwo or more transformations one after anotherreflect, then translate
orderwhich move comes firstthe order matters
congruentexactly the same size and shapea shape and its translation
similarthe same shape, possibly a different sizea shape and its enlargement
describe fullygive every detail needed to repeat the movereflection in the line y = x

Sentence starters for explaining aloud or in writing:

Two things not to say

“It does not matter which you do first.” It can.

“It is just a reflection.” Which line? A full description names it.

“Both points match, so it is right.” Check all of them.

Questions to set

Extra practice in three tiers, including one question from earlier work for spacing. Every answer has been checked.

1Fluency

The idea on its own, with friendly numbers. Set these first.

  1. CombineReflect (2, 6) in the y-axis, then translate by (1, −4).
    (−1, 2).
  2. Earlier work, enlargementEnlarge (−2, 3) by scale factor 5 from the origin.
    (−10, 15).

2In context

The same idea inside a situation, where the first job is deciding what to calculate.

  1. Identify(1, 2) goes to (3, 4) and (0, 5) goes to (2, 7). Describe the transformation.
    A translation by (2, 2).
  2. OrderTranslate (0, 0) by (4, 0), then enlarge by 2 from the origin. Then do it in the other order. Compare.
    (8, 0) and (4, 0): different.

3Challenge

Reasoning, generalizing and working backwards.

  1. ReasoningA square is reflected, rotated and translated. Does its perimeter change? Why?
    No: all three keep lengths.
  2. Earlier work, rotationsTurn (−3, 2) through 90° anticlockwise about the origin.
    (−2, −3).

Practicalities

Works on a phone or a shared screen. Nothing a student types is saved or sent anywhere.

Both figures work with the keyboard (tab to a button or slider, then the arrow keys) and by touch. Under each one, “Show me the steps” gives the same states in words.

No device? Squared paper and three colours: pre-image, first image and final image.