Year 11 Standard · Unit 3 · Lesson 7 · teacher page

Teaching: when the subject appears twice

Last lesson's method undoes steps one at a time. This lesson deals with formulas where that is impossible because the letter is in more than one place, and the answer is to factorize.

Number and AlgebraNo calculator

At a glance. One lesson of about 60 minutes. It assumes lesson 6 and factorizing a common factor. Students collect terms, factorize, divide by a bracket, clear fractions and substitute into the result.

Calculator: no calculator. All the substitutions work with small whole numbers or simple fractions, so no calculator is needed.

What students will learn

Know

  • Terms in the subject go on one side and the rest on the other.
  • A common factor of the subject is taken out and then divided away.
  • A fraction is cleared by multiplying both sides by its denominator.

Understand

  • Factorizing turns two appearances of the subject into one.
  • The bracket divides as a whole.
  • A quadratic in the subject cannot be solved by this method.

Do

  • Collect, factorize and divide.
  • Clear fractions, expand, then collect.
  • Substitute into the rearranged formula and check.

MYP assessment criteria

Wording paraphrased. What this lesson gives you evidence for, and what to look for:

The one thing to do with the figure

Ask for the prediction first. Then keep x fixed and change a and b, asking what happens to the total. Ask what number the total is divided by to get back to x.

Ask: “Why can we join the two rectangles?” Because they have the same height x, which is exactly what a common factor means.

A possible order

5 minWarm-up from the student page, in silence, then answers.
5 minHook: the two gym plans; write the equation.
12 minFigure, key idea, warning card.
8 minWorked examples; pairs finish the faded example.
5 minQuestion 1, the check. If many choose C, ask what divides by a bracket.
20 minYour turn, Levels 1 to 3, at each student's own pace.
5 minSomething to think about, then the exit ticket, question 8.

The answers

Warm-upx = (y − 9) ÷ 4; 3(2x + 5); x = 5.
Hook40 + 5n = 10 + 8n gives 30 = 3n, so n = 10: the plans cost the same after 10 classes. Plan B has the lower monthly fee, so it is cheaper for fewer than 10 classes, and plan A is cheaper for more.
Worked examplesx = (d − b) ÷ (a − c); p = T ÷ (q + 1); x = (2y + 1) ÷ (y − 3).
Faded examplea = c ÷ (b + d).
1. Collecting and factorizing the subjectA. B leaves x on the right; C divides one term; D keeps the sign of x when it moves.
2. Using a factorized formula6. 72 ÷ 12.
3. Subject on both sides7. 4x = 28.
4. Subject in a fraction3. 2x = 6.
5. Factorizing to find P1300. 1560 ÷ 1.2.
6. Subject in a denominator3. 1/v = 1/3.
7. A square in the formula2. a = 2(s − ut) ÷ t².
8. Collect, factorize, divideC. A subtracts c; B adds d; D divides by b only.

What each wrong answer tells you

They giveWhat it usually meansWhat to do
B, C or D in question 1Left x on both sides, divided one term, or kept the sign of x when moving it.Test k = 3 (so x = 3) in each option.
9 or 2.25 in question 2Divided by a only, or by ab.Write 8x + 4x = 12x first.
5 or 2.8 in question 3Subtracted q instead of adding, or added the x coefficients.Draw the balance: x terms left, numbers right, signs flip.
6 or 0 in question 4Stopped before dividing, or moved a term without changing sign.Write each line and say the operation aloud.
7800 or 1559.8 in question 5Divided by rt only, or subtracted rt.Ask: is P multiplied by 1, by rt, or by their sum?
−4 or 1.5 in question 6Treated reciprocals as numbers, or added.Use fractions with common denominators.
1 or 8 in question 7Forgot to double, or divided by t.Ask: what is t squared when t = 4?
A, B or D in question 8Subtracted c, added d, or divided by b only.Substitute small numbers into both sides of each option.

Questions worth asking

Differentiation

A way in for anyone stuck

Stretch

Students learning in English as an additional language

“Collect” means bring together. “Factorize” means write as a product, here taking the common letter out of a bracket. “Denominator” is the bottom of a fraction. “Common factor” is a number or letter that divides every term. “Reciprocal” means one divided by the number.

WordPlain meaningExample
collectbring terms together on one side of a formulaput the t terms on the left
factorizewrite as a product with a common factor taken out10k + 15 = 5(2k + 3)
common factora letter or number that divides every termm in km + 3m
denominatorthe bottom number or expression of a fractionthe w − 1 in 4 ÷ (w − 1)
reciprocal1 divided by a number1⁄8 is the reciprocal of 8

Sentence starters for explaining aloud or in writing:

Two things not to say

“Swap sides and flip.” Say instead: do the same operation to both sides.

“Cancel the letter.” Say instead: factorize the letter out of the bracket, then divide.

Questions to set

Extra practice in three tiers, including one question from earlier work for spacing. Every answer has been checked.

1Fluency

The idea on its own, with friendly numbers. Set these first.

  1. RearrangeMake x the subject of 7x + 2x = 63.
    x = 63 ÷ 9 = 7.
  2. RearrangeSolve 3x + 1 = x + 11.
    x = 5.

2In context

The same idea inside a situation, where the first job is deciding what to calculate.

  1. ContextTwo cinema plans in Lima cost 6 + 2n and 2 + 3n for n films. For which n are they equal?
    6 + 2n = 2 + 3n gives n = 4.
  2. Earlier work (lesson 6)Make y the subject of x = 3y − 7.
    y = (x + 7) ÷ 3.

3Challenge

Reasoning, generalizing and working backwards.

  1. ReasoningMake x the subject of y = (2x + 3) ÷ (x − 1).
    yx − y = 2x + 3, so x(y − 2) = y + 3 and x = (y + 3) ÷ (y − 2).
  2. Working backwardsa = (c + e) ÷ (b − d). Find e when a = 4, b = 6, d = 2 and c = 5.
    4 × 4 = 16 = 5 + e, so e = 11.

Practicalities

Works on a phone or a shared screen. Nothing a student types is saved or sent anywhere.

The figure works with the keyboard (tab to a slider, then the arrow keys) and by touch. “Show me the steps” gives the same states in words.

No device? Cut two paper rectangles of equal height and join them.