Year 11 Standard · Unit 1 · Lesson 4 · teacher page

Teaching: histograms with unequal widths

Students have drawn bar charts and frequency tables. A histogram with unequal classes breaks the habit that height means count, and the lesson moves the meaning to area.

Statistics and ProbabilityNo calculator

At a glance. One lesson of about 60 minutes. It assumes grouped data (Lesson 1) and area of a rectangle. Students find frequency density, read frequencies from areas, draw a histogram from a table, and estimate a median by area.

Calculator: no calculator. No calculator is needed: the divisions and products are chosen to be short, and the idea that area means frequency is the reasoning.

What students will learn

Know

  • Frequency density = frequency divided by class width.
  • The area of a bar is the frequency.
  • Class width = upper boundary minus lower boundary.

Understand

  • Height shows how crowded the values are, not how many there are.
  • A wide, low bar can hold more values than a narrow, tall one.
  • The modal class of unequal classes has the highest density.

Do

  • Compute frequency density from a table.
  • Read frequencies and totals from bars.
  • Estimate a median by locating the middle value inside its class.

MYP assessment criteria

Wording paraphrased. What this lesson gives you evidence for, and what to look for:

The one thing to do with the figure

Make students commit before they press. In the first figure, ask “When the height becomes frequency density, which bar will be the tallest?” and take a class number from each pair before pressing the button.

In the second figure, ask what happens to the area if the width doubles and the frequency stays the same, then check with the sliders.

A possible order

5 minWarm-up from the student page, in silence, then answers.
7 minHook: the age bands. Collect predictions about the biggest bar and the busiest band.
10 minFirst figure and key idea: density and area.
10 minSecond figure, the warning card and the worked example; pairs finish the faded example.
5 minThe check. If many choose B or D, return to the rectangle: what is its area?
18 minYour turn, Levels 1 to 3, at each student's own pace.
5 minSomething to think about, then the exit ticket, question 8.

The answers

Warm-up50; 24; 5.
HookWith height as frequency a wide band can look largest because it covers more years. The busiest band per year of age is the one with the greatest density, which needs each count divided by its width.
Worked example30, 42 and 24, total 96.
Faded exampleHeights 3.6, 3 and 1.3.
1. Frequency from a barC. A adds; B divides width by height; D divides height by width.
2. Frequency density4.5. 54 ÷ 12.
3. Frequency from height and width18. 5 × 3.6.
4. Density from class boundaries2.2. 33 ÷ 15.
5. Total from a histogram84. 18 + 48 + 18.
6. Same frequency, a different width1.2. 24 ÷ 20.
7. A median from a histogram16.25. 15 + 10 × 5 ÷ 40.
8. Frequency of one barD. A is the height; B uses the lower boundary as the width; C uses the upper boundary.

What each wrong answer tells you

They giveWhat it usually meansWhat to do
A, B or D in question 1Adds, divides the wrong way, or divides height by width.Sketch the rectangle and label its sides.
648, 42 or 66 in question 2Multiplied, subtracted or added the frequency and the width.Ask: is it values per unit of width? What does 'per' mean?
0.72, 8.6 or 3.6 in question 3Divided, added, or gave the height as the frequency.Ask for the area of the rectangle in square units.
3.3, 1.32 or 48 in question 4Used a boundary as the width, or added.Subtract the boundaries to find the width first.
4.8, 48 or 66 in question 5Added the heights, used a common width, or left out a bar.Write each class's frequency in a column, then add.
4.8, 2.4 or 19.2 in question 6Kept the height, used a boundary as the width, or multiplied.Find the frequency first, then redistribute.
20, 55 or 25 in question 7Took the midpoint of the class, a position, or the class end.Count 50 values, then ask how many more are needed to reach 55.
A, B or C in question 8Gave the height, or used a boundary as the width.Subtract the boundaries to find the width.

Questions worth asking

Differentiation

A way in for anyone stuck

Stretch

Students learning in English as an additional language

“Density” here means how crowded something is. “Frequency density” is the number of values per unit. “Class width” is how wide a class is. “Area” is width times height of a rectangle.

WordPlain meaningExample
histograma graph of continuous data in which the area of each bar is the frequencybars with no gaps and a density axis
frequency densityfrequency divided by class widthvalues per minute of waiting time
class widthupper boundary minus lower boundarythe width of the class 30 to under 45
continuous datadata that can take any value on a scaleheights or times
areawidth times height; in a histogram, the frequencythe size of a bar
modal classthe class with the highest frequency densitythe tallest bar when the heights show density

Sentence starters for explaining aloud or in writing:

Two things not to say

“The tallest bar has the most values.” Only if the classes have equal width; otherwise compare area.

“Leave gaps between the bars.” A histogram is for continuous data, so the bars touch.

Questions to set

Extra practice in three tiers, including one question from earlier work for spacing. Every answer has been checked.

1Fluency

The idea on its own, with friendly numbers. Set these first.

  1. DensityFrequency 40, width 8. Find the frequency density.
    5.
  2. FrequencyA bar is 6 wide and 2.5 tall. Find the frequency.
    15.

2In context

The same idea inside a situation, where the first job is deciding what to calculate.

  1. ContextA class of 30 to under 50 minutes of daily screen time holds 45 students. What height is drawn for its bar?
    45 ÷ 20 = 2.25.
  2. Earlier work (Lesson 2)A curve for 80 values reads the median at which count?
    40.

3Challenge

Reasoning, generalizing and working backwards.

  1. ReasoningTwo bars have equal area. One is three times as wide as the other. How do their heights compare?
    The wider one is a third as tall.
  2. Working backwardsA histogram has a total area of 150. One bar has height 3 and width 10. What fraction of the values are in it?
    30 ÷ 150 = 1/5.

Practicalities

Works on a phone or a shared screen. Nothing a student types is saved or sent anywhere.

Both figures work with the keyboard (tab to a slider or button, then the arrow keys or Enter) and by touch. Under each one, “Show me the steps” gives the same states in words.

No device? Use squared paper and let one square stand for 2 values: draw the bars and count squares to check the area.