Year 11 Extended · Unit 1 · Lesson 3 · teacher page

Teaching: exact values and proof with surds

Students met 30°, 45° and 60° in Year 10 as values to remember. This lesson asks them to derive the values from two triangles, use them with no calculator, and then build a value no one told them, tan 15°.

Geometry and TrigonometryNo calculator

At a glance. One lesson of about 60 minutes, no calculator. Students derive the exact ratios from half an equilateral triangle and half a square, use them in lengths, areas and equations, and prove tan 15° = 2 − √3 from an isosceles construction.

Calculator: no calculator. No calculator is used: exact values and surds are done by hand, and a decimal is shown only as a check.

What students will learn

Know

  • sin, cos and tan of 30°, 45° and 60° exactly.
  • The sides of a 30, 60, 90 triangle are k, k√3 and 2k; of a 45, 45, 90 triangle k, k and k√2.
  • How to rationalize a denominator, including 1 ÷ (2 + √3).

Understand

  • The ratios are the same at every size because the triangles are similar.
  • A new exact value can be built by using the known ones inside a larger construction.

Do

  • Use exact values to find lengths and areas.
  • Prove a statement with surds without rounding.
  • Construct an exact value, tan 15°.

MYP assessment criteria

Wording paraphrased. What this lesson gives you evidence for, and what to look for:

The one thing to do with the figure

Make students predict, then reveal. Before the first figure, ask them to guess whether the longest side of the 10 cm set square is a whole number. Then set the hypotenuse to 20 and the angle to 30°.

In the second figure, let students change k and say what changes and what does not.

A possible order

5 minWarm-up from the student page, in silence, then answers.
5 minHook: the set square. Collect votes and reasons.
12 minFirst figure; key idea derivation; settle the hook; the warning card.
10 minSecond figure; worked examples 1 to 3; pairs finish the faded example.
5 minQuestion 1, the check. If many choose A, return to which leg is longer.
18 minYour turn, Levels 1 to 3, at each student's own pace.
5 minSomething to think about, then the exit ticket, question 9.

The answers

Warm-up4√3; 2√5; 7√2 cm.
Worked examples25√3 cm²; √3/3; tan 15° = 2 − √3.
Faded example1/2.
Something to think aboutNot true: √3/2 against 1; and √2 against 1.
1. A side of a 30, 60, 90 triangleB. A multiplies by √3; C halves; D treats 9 as the hypotenuse.
2. Area of a 30, 60, 90 triangle from the hypotenuse24.5. ½ × 7 × 7√3.
3. A product of exact values6. √2 × √3 = √6.
4. Perimeter of a 30, 60, 90 triangle37.9 cm. 24 + 8√3.
5. A shadow from the exact tan 15 degrees112 m. 30(2 + √3).
6. Solving with an exact value30°. tan x = 1 ÷ √3.
7. Area of a regular hexagon54. 6 × 9√3.
8. Two special triangles sharing a side2.93 cm. 4√3 − 4.
9. Hypotenuse of a right isosceles triangle from its areaC. A divides the leg by √2; B gives the leg; D doubles the leg.

What each wrong answer tells you

They giveWhat it usually meansWhat to do
A, C or D in question 1Multiplied by √3, halved, or treated 9 as the hypotenuse.Ask: is the side opposite 30° the longest or the shortest leg? Then divide.
49 or 12.25 in question 2Left out the half, or halved twice.Draw the triangle, label both legs, and use half base times height.
3 or 9 in question 3Used sin 30° or sin 60° in place of sin 45°.Ask them to write each exact value as a surd before multiplying.
21.9 or 35.3 in question 4Left out the hypotenuse, or used 45° values.Mark the three sides of the triangle on a sketch and add all three.
8 or 104 in question 5Multiplied by tan 15°, or halved tan 30°.Ask: which side is the mast, which the shadow? Then which ratio?
60 or 45 in question 6Multiplied, or dropped the √3.Divide both sides by √3 and then find the angle in the table.
108 or 27 in question 7Left out the half, or counted three triangles.Draw the six triangles from the centre; count them.
1.27 or 10.93 in question 8Took BD as a hypotenuse, or added.Name the two triangles; find BC and BD separately, then subtract.
A, B or D in question 9Divided the leg by √2, gave the leg, or doubled it as in a 30, 60, 90 triangle.Ask: which side is the longest, and what is the ratio of the sides of half a square?

Questions worth asking

Differentiation

A way in for anyone stuck

Stretch

Students learning in English as an additional language

“Exact” means written with the square root, not a rounded decimal. “Rationalize” means remove the root from the bottom of a fraction. “Isosceles” has two equal sides; use a picture of the set square and the triangle.

WordPlain meaningExample
exact valuea number written with its roots and fractions, not rounded√3/2, not 0.866
surda root that does not come out as a whole number or fraction√5
rationalizerewrite a fraction so the bottom has no root1/√2 becomes √2/2
isoscelesa triangle with two equal sides and two equal anglesa triangle with two sides of 5 cm
exterior anglethe angle outside a triangle formed by extending a sideequals the sum of the two opposite interior angles

Sentence starters for explaining aloud or in writing:

Two things not to say

“Just memorize the table.” Show where each value comes from.

“Use 1.73.” In a proof, keep the root.

Questions to set

Extra practice in three tiers, including one question from earlier work for spacing. Every answer has been checked.

1Fluency

The idea on its own, with friendly numbers. Set these first.

  1. Exact valueWrite the exact value of cos 45° × sin 30°.
    √2/4.
  2. Earlier work (Year 10)Rationalize 6 ÷ √2.
    3√2.

2In context

The same idea inside a situation, where the first job is deciding what to calculate.

  1. LengthA 30, 60, 90 triangle has a short side of 5 cm. Find the perimeter, as an exact value.
    15 + 5√3 cm.
  2. EquationSolve 2 cos x = 1 for an acute x.
    60°.

3Challenge

Reasoning, generalizing and working backwards.

  1. ReasoningShow that sin²60° + cos²60° = 1 using exact values.
    3/4 + 1/4 = 1.
  2. OpenAn equilateral triangle has height 9 cm. Find its side and its area exactly.
    Side 6√3 cm, area 27√3 cm².

Practicalities

Works on a phone or a shared screen. Nothing a student types is saved or sent anywhere.

Both figures work with the keyboard (tab to a slider, then the arrow keys) and by touch. “Show me the steps” gives the same states in words.

No device? Two set squares from a geometry box give the two special triangles directly.