Topic 5.1 · AA and AI, SL and HL

A curve has no gradient until you stop using two points

Where the derivative comes from, how to estimate a limit without any algebra, and what a rate of change actually tells you.

You can find the gradient of a straight line because you can pick two points on it. On a curve, every pair of points gives a different answer, and none of them is the gradient at a point.

So watch what happens when the two points move together. P is fixed at (1, 1). Q slides down the curve towards it. Press play.

h = 1.50
3.50gradient of PQ
5.25rise
1.50run

Drag the slider yourself, or press play. Nothing is stored and nothing is sent anywhere.

Estimating the limit from a table

This is the whole method. Shrink h, write down the gradient, and see what the numbers are heading towards. Rows fill in as the animation passes them.

hQgradient of PQ
1(2, 4)–
0.5(1.5, 2.25)–
0.1(1.1, 1.21)–
0.01(1.01, 1.0201)–
towards 0towards P–

The gradients are 3, 2.5, 2.1, 2.01. They are not reaching 2 by accident: for this curve the gradient of PQ is exactly 2 + h, so as h shrinks the answer is squeezed towards 2.

That number, 2, is the gradient of the tangent at P, and it is what we mean by the derivative at x = 1.

You are not asked to find limits by algebra on this course. You are asked to estimate one from a table or a graph, which is exactly what you just did. If a question gives you a table of values and asks what the gradient is approaching, that is the whole task.

Four ways of writing the same thing

Examiners switch between these freely, and a question about a balloon will not use the letter x. They all mean "the rate at which the top variable changes when the bottom one changes".

WrittenSay it asUsed when
dydxdee y by dee xy is a function of x
f′(x)f prime of xyou were given f(x)
dVdrdee V by dee rvolume changing with radius
dsdtdee s by dee tdistance changing with time

A derivative is a rate of change

This is the half of 5.1 that carries the marks, and it has nothing to do with limits.

Worked example: the cost of one more

A workshop's cost in baht for making x chairs is C(x) = 0.02x² + 5x + 200, and its derivative is C′(x) = 0.04x + 5.

C′(100)= 0.04 × 100 + 5 = 4 + 5 = 9 baht per chair Check it against the real jump: C(101) − C(100) = 9.02 baht.

So at 100 chairs, making one more chair adds about 9 baht. That sentence is the answer. "The derivative is 9" is not, because it does not say nine of what, per what.

Units come free, and they are marks. The units of a derivative are always the top units divided by the bottom units. Baht per chair. Litres per second. Marks per hour of revision. If you can say the units you usually have the interpretation.

Worked example: a balloon

A spherical balloon has volume V = 43πr³, and dVdr = 4πr².

dVdr= 4π × 3² = 36π ≈ 113.1 cm³ per cm, at r = 3

When the radius is 3 cm, the volume is growing at about 113 cm³ for every extra cm of radius. Notice it is not constant: the same balloon at r = 6 grows four times as fast, because the derivative has an r² in it.

Your turn

1. A table shows the gradient of a chord as 4.3, 4.1, 4.02, 4.001 for shrinking h. Estimate the gradient of the tangent.

2. For the chair workshop, C′(100) = 9. What does that mean?

3. For the balloon, dVdr = 4πr². Find the rate when r = 3, to one decimal place.

Where the marks go

Reading a limit off a table is one mark and almost free, once you know that is what is being asked. Do not try to do algebra to it.

Interpreting a derivative in context with units is the mark people lose. "9" earns nothing. "At 100 chairs, one more chair costs about 9 baht" earns it.

Watch the letters. A question about a cone will ask for dV/dh or dV/dr, and they are different derivatives of the same formula. Read which variable is changing before you differentiate anything.

Want a verdict on your own draft?

These pages are free and stay free, but they are general and your IA is not. Send me your research question, or whatever exists so far, and I will tell you in writing whether the topic has a ceiling on it, where the marks are going, and what to change first. That costs nothing and it comes back within 24 hours.

Written by a serving IB Diploma and Career-related Programme Coordinator and Head of Mathematics, who reads internal assessments across every subject group every year. If you then want the whole draft reviewed properly against all five criteria, that is the paid one, and it is refunded if it does not name at least three specific things to fix.

Get a free verdict Full written review, $99

I never write any part of it. Not a sentence, not a calculation, not your data. Under 18: a parent buys this and the thread is with them. I do not work with students at my own school.