Topic 3.9 · Applications and Interpretation HL

Same determinant, different transformation

Rotate then reflect, and the flag lands in one place. Reflect then rotate, and it lands somewhere else. Both compositions have determinant −1, so the determinant cannot tell you which one you did.

the flag, before anything
(2, 0)where (2, 0) lands
1determinant
no change yetverdict

The same two matrices in the two possible orders give two different transformations and one determinant.

The matrices you are given

TransformationMatrixDeterminant
Reflection in the x-axis(1, 0; 0, −1)−1
Reflection in the y-axis(−1, 0; 0, 1)−1
Reflection in y = x(0, 1; 1, 0)−1
Reflection in y = −x(0, −1; −1, 0)−1
Reflection in y = x tanθ(cos2θ, sin2θ; sin2θ, −cos2θ)−1
Rotation through θ anticlockwise(cosθ, −sinθ; sinθ, cosθ)1
Stretch, factor p horizontally, q vertically(p, 0; 0, q)pq
Enlargement, scale factor k, centre the origin(k, 0; 0, k)k²

Written as (a, b; c, d), the first pair is the top row. The general reflection is the one to check on the formula booklet, because θ there is the angle of the MIRROR LINE and the matrix uses 2θ; at θ = 45° it gives (0, 1; 1, 0), the reflection in y = x, which is the quickest way to confirm you have it the right way round. You do not have to memorise any of the others: the first column is where (1, 0) goes and the second column is where (0, 1) goes. Draw the two arrows and you have written the matrix.

Translations are not matrix multiplication. Every matrix here fixes the origin, because a matrix times the zero vector is always zero. A translation moves the origin, so it is a vector you add, not a matrix you multiply by. A transformation that both turns and shifts is written Mx + b.

Composition: the order is part of the answer

Let R be a 90° anticlockwise rotation and M a reflection in the x-axis.

R = (0, −1; 1, 0)   and   M = (1, 0; 0, −1)

Rotate first, then reflect is the matrix MR, because the one that acts first sits closest to the vector:

MR = (0, −1; −1, 0), which is a reflection in y = −x. It sends (1, 0) to (0, −1).

Reflect first, then rotate is RM:

RM = (0, 1; 1, 0), which is a reflection in y = x. It sends (1, 0) to (0, 1).

Two different transformations. Two different mirror lines, perpendicular to each other. And:

det(MR) = −1   and   det(RM) = −1

So the determinant is not a name. It tells you two things and no more: its size is the factor every area is multiplied by, and its sign says whether the shape was flipped over. −1 means "same area, flipped", and there are infinitely many transformations that do that. If you want to know which, multiply the matrix by (1, 0) and by (0, 1) and see where they go.

What the determinant does tell you

Take the stretch S = (2, 0; 0, 3), with det S = 2 × 3 = 6.

  1. The unit square, area 1, becomes a 2 by 3 rectangle, area 6.
  2. A triangle of area 4 becomes a triangle of area 4 × 6 = 24.
  3. Any shape at all has its area multiplied by 6. That is what an area scale factor means.

And the sign: det M = −1 for a reflection, and the minus sign is not about area, which is 1 either way. It records that a shape traced anticlockwise comes out traced clockwise. Area uses the size of the determinant, so take the absolute value.

A determinant of 0 is the interesting one. (2, 4; 1, 2) has determinant 2×2 − 4×1 = 0, and it squashes the whole plane onto a single line. Every area becomes 0, nothing can be undone, and the matrix has no inverse. A zero determinant is the warning that information has been destroyed.

On the GDC: matrices and determinants

Both machines multiply matrices and take determinants directly, which means the only thing left for you to get wrong is the order. Type both orders and look at them.

When you may use it. Applications. A calculator is allowed in every paper, and matrix work is exactly the sort of arithmetic the course expects you to hand over. Enter the matrices, read the product, and spend your time on which order the question described.

TI-Nspire CX II

  1. In a Calculator page, ctrl × gives a 2 by 2 matrix template, which is exactly what a plane transformation needs
  2. Fill it, then ctrl var to store it as r, and the same again for m
  3. m*r gives (0,-1;-1,0) and r*m gives (0,1;1,0). Different products, which is the point
  4. menu → Matrix & Vector → Determinant, or type det(m*r): -1, and det(r*m) is -1 too

Casio fx-CG50

  1. MENU → Run-Matrix, then F3 MAT/VCT
  2. Select Mat A, set the dimension to 2 by 2, enter R; then Mat B for M, and EXIT
  3. Mat B x Mat A then EXE; then Mat A x Mat B. Compare the two screens
  4. For the determinant: OPTN → F2 MAT/VCT → Det, applied to each product. Both give -1

The mark people lose. Multiplying in the order the words appear. "Rotate, then reflect" becomes MR, with the rotation on the RIGHT, because it is the one that touches the vector first. Writing RM there gives a reflection in the other line, a wrong image, and a determinant that looks perfectly healthy. Both machines will happily compute the wrong product. The check is to send (1, 0) through by hand and see whether the answer matches the picture.

Your turn

1. Find the determinant of (2, 0; 0, 3).

2. A triangle of area 4 is transformed by that matrix. What is the new area?

3. What is the determinant of a rotation through 30°?

4. The point (2, 0) is rotated 90° anticlockwise and then reflected in the x-axis. Give the y-coordinate of where it lands.

5. Two different composite matrices both have determinant −1. What does that tell you?

Question 5. Two different composite matrices both have determinant minus 1. What does that tell you?
Where the marks go

1 markEach transformation's matrix, written correctly.

1 markThe product, in the right order.

1 markThe image, or the determinant, or the area factor, as asked.

The order mark is the one people drop. Write the matrix of the FIRST transformation on the right of the product, every time, and write it down before you reach for the calculator.

Want a verdict on your own draft?

These pages are free and stay free, but they are general and your IA is not. Send me your research question, or whatever exists so far, and I will tell you in writing whether the topic has a ceiling on it, where the marks are going, and what to change first. That costs nothing and it comes back within 24 hours.

Written by a serving IB Diploma and Career-related Programme Coordinator and Head of Mathematics, who reads internal assessments across every subject group every year. If you then want the whole draft reviewed properly against all five criteria, that is the paid one, and it is refunded if it does not name at least three specific things to fix.

Send me your question, free

Already have a full draft? Have the whole thing reviewed against all five criteria, $99.